Category CRITERIA

Each award category features it’s own mix of the criteria listed below and the weighting for each criteria in each category is different – the relevant criteria and weighting breakdown can be seen on the individual category pages. The online submission process will also outline for you the criteria you will need to respond to based on the category you have chosen to enter.

Criteria Explanations

Urban Form

Urban Form is the catchall for the planning/design process and its outcomes. It includes the design response to the site and the vision of the developer. This can include reference to innovations in the street pattern, layout and circulation; design responses to topographical or unique features of the site; lot design and orientation; location of facilities; built form objectives; public open space and landscaping. Judges will be looking for commentary on the following:

  • Planning
  • Overall Design
  • Streetscape and circulation
  • Landscaping
  • Built form
  • Contextual relationships

 

Buildings

This section is for the Judges to assess the quality of the buildings. Judges will be looking for information on the following:

  • Architectural Merit
  • Community Facilities
  • Execution, Finishes and Inclusions

 

Community Creation and Integration

This section recognises the important role of the development in community creation and integration. This criterion may be addressed under some or all the headings below or other headings that are relevant to the project. Mandatory components must be included

  • Meaningful Community Involvement (mandatory for Masterplanned Development)
  • Community Planning, Development and Capacity Building (mandatory for Masterplanned Development)
  • Affordable Housing
  • Equity and Diversity
  • Safety and Security
  • Cultural Heritage
  • Provision/Access to Relevant Infrastructure

 

Environmental Sustainability, Integrated Water Management, and Engineering Considerations

This section recognises the role of the developer in managing and encouraging environmental sustainability. This may be addressed under some or all the headings below or other headings that are relevant to the project.

  • Soil and Water Management
  • Transport, Access and Connectivity
  • Neutral Environment, Landscape, Native Species and Vegetation
  • Energy Efficiency/Reduction of Greenhouse Emissions
  • Cultural Heritage
  • Micro Climate
  • Visual Environment
  • Materials and Inclusions
  • Reduction in Waste and Waste to Landfill
  • Integrated Water Cycle Management

Any aspect of engineering for the project and includes key engineering objectives for the site, significant site constraints and how these matters were addressed through engineering design, water management including storm water, wastewater, drainage, surface and ground water solutions and key innovations and solutions.

 

Heritage Considerations

This may cover any aspect of the development from the planning to the built form. Any aspect of the Environmental Sustainability section outlined on the following page may be used as well as the environmental performance of the building. Heritage considerations will vary significantly between developments and may not be relevant in some cases.

 

Innovation and Unique Features

The Judges are looking for what makes your project “special” and or what was done that hasn’t or has been rarely tried before. This is the opportunity to really highlight why your project stands out from the rest.

 

Access to Employment

Projects must demonstrate how they have improved access to employment either through the creation of permanent places of employment; adaptability of homes for home businesses; or by designing the layout of the development in a way that utilises the site’s proximity to existing employment or public transport.

 

Problem Solving, Consultation, Negotiation, Issues Resolution

This criterion provides an opportunity for you to summarise the problems that the development team experienced throughout the development process and how these were overcome. There are many examples such as the site may have had problems relating to contamination or acid sulphate soils, rare or endangered species, wetlands, access to facilities or services, location within a low socioeconomic demographic. The emphasis is on how these problems were resolved with a focus on community consultation, working with key stakeholders such as other land holders in the area, Local, State or Federal Government.

 

Affordability

This award recognises excellence in the delivery of affordable housing that is appropriate for the needs of a range of very low to moderate income households and priced so that these households are able to meet basic living costs.

As a rule of thumb, housing is usually considered affordable if it costs less than 30% of gross household income. Entrants should demonstrate initial affordability of the product and incorporate ‘whole of life’ sustainable elements that provide for ongoing affordability. Entries for projects funded under the National Rental Affordability Scheme, new generation boarding house developments, and other affordable housing products from private developers and not-for-profit organisations are encouraged to enter.

 

Landscaping

Consideration will be given to the contribution that landscaping makes to the project. The Judges will consider the nature and type of landscaping as well as the integration of native vegetation, preservation/protection of existing habitats, and the incorporation of new and innovative landscaping ideas.

 

State & Local Planning Objectives

Consideration will be given to the extent to which projects have considered local planning policies and objectives and either met them or demonstrated an acceptable alternative approach.

 

Execution, Finishes & Inclusions

Where the project includes the built product, consideration will be given to the quality, layout and design of external and internal finishes, fixtures and fittings.

 

Regeneration History

Provide insight into the unique history of the subject site and or its surrounding area. Describe the ways that the development has integrated with the existing built environment and/or retained elements of its history.

 

Healthy Design

This section recognises the role of the built environment in the health of the community. Applicants should address how they have responded to each of the Healthy Design Considerations of:

  • walking & cycling routes – to provide an accessible integrated network of walking and cycling routes for safe and convenient travel to local destinations and points of interest
  • streets – to design legible street networks that provide direct, safe and convenient pedestrian and cycle access. To position pedestrian crossings along streets and roads with heavy traffic volumes
  • local destinations – to provide local destinations to support lively, walkable and rideable neighbourhoods
  • open space – to provide a range of public open spaces within walking distance from dwellings. To clearly define walking and cycling routes that pass through open spaces and incorporate these routes into the broader walking and cycling network
  • public transport – to establish and promote clear and direct walking and cycling routes to public transport stops and appealing and convenient facilities for users
  • supporting infrastructure – to provide seating, signage, lighting and consideration for low walls and transparent fencing
  • fostering community spirit – to develop built environment and community participation strategies that foster active communities and a sense of community spirit

 

Housing Diversity

The project includes a variety of different housing products that encourages a diversity of households within the project site or its surrounds. This includes both household sizes and/or household socio-economics (Age, Income, etc.).

 

Marketing and Financial Structure/Performance/Acceptance

This section should include the approach taken to market the project including any marketing themes developed for the project along with initiatives implemented through the marketing campaign. The Judges will be looking for clear insight into the commercial success of the project including market acceptance. All information for the Judges remains strictly confidential. You may consider including completion within budget, percentage return achieved by the development company and the influence of the project’s success on other projects being undertaken by the development company.

JUDGING CRITERIA

The Judging Criteria is to be used as a guide when compiling your submission. The table below lists criteria that must be addressed for each category including weighting out of 100 %.

CRITERIA Masterplanned Development Residential Development
(greater or less than 250 lots)
Medium Density  High Density Development
(below and above 10 storey’s)
Small Scale Development  Urban Renewal Environmental
Excellence
Affordable Development Special Purpose Developing
inc.  Seniors Living
Great Place Award
Urban Form 15 15 15 15 15 15 10 10 10 10
Buildings 15 15 15 10 5 10 10
Community Creation & Integration 15 15 10 10 10 10 5 10 10 15
Environmental sustainability, integrated water management & Engineering matters 15 15 5 5 5 5 40 5 5 5
Heritage Considerations 15
Innovation & Unique Features 5 5 5 5 5 5 10 5 5 10
Access to employment 5 5 10
Problem Solving, Consultation, Negotiation, Issues Resolution 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 10
Affordability 5 5 5 5 5 5 20 10
Landscaping 5 5 5 5 5 5 10
State & Local Planning Objectives 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Execution, Finishes & Inclusions 10 10 10 5 5
Regeneration History 15
Healthy Design 5 5 5 5 5 10 10
Housing Diversity 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Marketing and Financial Structure/Performance/

Acceptance

5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Judges’ Overall Impressions 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
TOTAL 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%